Submit your: Art / Comics / Poetry / Reviews / Stories

Fiction Nation: To the North and South with Elizabeth Gaskell

by Allana Luta

Now I know January usually signals beginnings but I can’t help feeling the beginnings of that time of year when there’s more pollen in the air, love songs are heard everywhere and couples make out in public like they just don’t care. (Points for the rhyme, please.)

February is still a week away, but why not get a head start, eh? Because right now, Elizabeth’s Gaskell’s North and South has already gotten me in the mo-hoood for looo-hoove… or at least longing stares and soft, electrifying touches of the hand. Let’s get our hearts racin’!

Published in 1855, North and South is a Victorian novel written by Elizabeth Gaskell. It is set during the Industrial Revolution and we are taken to the northern English town of Milton, mostly famous for its cotton mills and harsh, industrial lifestyle.

The two protagonists are Margaret Hale, a young lady from the south whose family recently moved to Milton, and John Thornton, owner of Marlborough Mills. The stark contrast in their personalities is one of the conflicts in the story but there’s so much more surrounding it.

But first, how did I come upon this wonderful gem? I didn’t. A friend knew how much I love Pride & Prejudice so she suggested a BBC serial she thought I might like. And boy, I fell.

This BBC adaptation, first aired in 2004, stars Daniela Denby-Ashe as Margaret and Richard Armitage as Thornton. It only has four hour-long episodes, so it’s very easy to binge-watch, yaknowwhatImean? After a sleep-deprived night, I was bewitched, body and soul, and I love, love, loved it and never wish to be parted from it again.

Oops, wrong adaptation.

You see, Margaret and Thornton’s relationship is reminiscent of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy’s. There’s the same push and pull going on between them, with the gruff, unfeeling gentleman being the first to develop feelings for the lady and getting rejected. There remains mutual respect but it only occurs to the lady later on that – gasp! – she also has romantic feelings for that unbearable-actually-quite-lovable man!

Every time we touch, the honesty’s too much…” You could cut the sexual tension between them with a butter knife. (Or bread knife, if that’s what’s you have.)

(By the way, does anybody else ever wonder why the women are known by their first names and the men by their surnames? Is this a gender thing or English thing? Am I missing something here? Do we need to tackle this in the future??? Am I asking too many questions?!?! Am I using too many exclamation and question marks???!!!???!!!)

Unlike P&P where it’s mostly from Lizzie’s point of view, we actually get to see what goes on in Thornton’s head because the novel is told through his perspective as well. And this makes him, for me, so much more fully-formed than Darcy. (DID I JUST BLASPHEME AGAINST DARCY? Forgive me for I have sinned!)

But that’s where the comparisons end. North and South is so much more than just a love story. Yes, Margaret and Thornton’s budding romance is the central narrative, but we are also introduced to the strained relationship between the masters and the workers. (Downton Abbey, anybody?) The context of class playing a very important role is so interesting that I didn’t mind that it deviated from the romance at all!

Another thing I loved? Margaret Hale is such a BOSS. Gaskell has written one of my favorite favourite female characters in fiction. Margaret is self-sacrificing, headstrong, and independent in a way that is absolutely admirable. In a span of a few years, she’s gone through so many changes and loss but has remained warmhearted and has made the most out of it. And during those dark moments, she never once asked help from a man. Bless her heart.

Margaret defening John Thornton from an angry mob: “This is where the path of hatred has brought us!”

There are so many other layers to the story that I haven’t even mentioned yet! Difficult family relations, differences in mindset between Northerners and Southerners, how faith, or lack thereof, affects how people deal with challenges and death; how Margaret completely shattered people’s expectations of how young ladies should behave, etc.

The serial was quite faithful to the book. Maybe not a hundred percent, because that would be impossible, but it was good enough for me to watch it again right after I finished reading the book. And I think I’m going to give it a go for a third time next month. So if you decide to watch along with me, let me know what you think! Happy falling in love with Margaret and Thornton! 




2 responses to “Fiction Nation: To the North and South with Elizabeth Gaskell”

  1. […] Hi, Cheer Readers! Welcome to another edition of Fiction Nation, where we geek out over adaptations of our favorite novels. (Check out the first one here!) […]


  2. […] “My fave female lit character is Margaret Hale from North & South, while my fave female author is… Anne Rice? Haha! […]


Anything to share? :)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: